Beyond the Nativity: 5 Surprising Truths Hidden in Matthew's Christmas Story
Introduction: More Than a Manger Scene
Think of a nativity scene. The image is one of serene stillness: a peaceful baby, reverent shepherds, and wise men gathered under a silent, starry night. It’s the version of Christmas we see on cards and in carols. But the first account of Jesus’s birth in the New Testament, the Gospel of Matthew, offers something entirely different. It is a story of political intrigue, divine strategy, and scriptural artistry that reads more like a theological thriller than a gentle bedtime story.
This article moves beyond the traditional manger scene to uncover five surprising truths hidden in Matthew's narrative. These takeaways reveal the deeper theological arguments the author was making, presenting a Christmas story that is as intellectually stunning as it is spiritually significant.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Matthew's "Fulfilled" Prophecies Were Creative Masterpieces, Not Simple Predictions.
To build his case for Jesus as the climax of Israel’s history, Matthew masterfully employs over 60 quotations from the Old Testament, many introduced with the phrase, "This was to fulfill what was spoken by the prophet." A closer look, however, reveals that Matthew’s method is not a modern, literalist checklist. He operates within an ancient Jewish interpretive tradition, using tools like typology and midrash, where scripture is understood to have a deeper, divinely intended meaning (sensus plenior). For Matthew, "fulfillment" was not about simple prediction but about showing how Jesus's life was the culmination and perfect expression of Israel’s entire story.
• The "Virgin" Birth Prophecy: Matthew famously quotes Isaiah 7:14: "Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son." Matthew was working from the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible that was the common scripture for many Jews of his time. The original Hebrew text used the word almah, which means "young woman," not necessarily a virgin, and the prophecy was originally a sign for King Ahaz in the 8th century BCE. By using the Greek translation's more specific word, parthenos (virgin), Matthew theologically connected a circulating story about Jesus’s miraculous conception to the sacred history of Israel.
• The "Out of Egypt" Prophecy: After the Holy Family flees to Egypt, Matthew quotes Hosea 11:1: "Out of Egypt I called My son." In its original context, this verse was a look back at the Exodus, referring to the nation of Israel as God's "son." This is a classic example of typology. Matthew presents Jesus as the new Israel, who not only relives but perfects the history of God's people. Where the nation of Israel, God's "first-born son" (Exodus 4:22), faltered, Jesus, as the true Son, succeeds.
• The "Nazarene" Prophecy: The final fulfillment prophecy in the birth narrative states, "He will be called a Nazarene" (Matthew 2:23). This is perhaps the most surprising of all because this exact prophecy does not exist anywhere in the Old Testament. Scholars believe Matthew is employing a sophisticated wordplay, linking the name of the town, Nazareth, to the Hebrew word for "branch" (nezer), a known messianic title from prophecies in Isaiah and Zechariah.
This reveals Matthew not as a mere chronicler ticking off a prophetic checklist, but as a sophisticated theologian weaving the entire story of Israel into the person of Jesus.
2. The First Christmas Story Was a "New Moses" Action Thriller.
Far from being a quiet, pastoral tale, Matthew's infancy narrative is structured as a high-stakes drama deliberately paralleling the birth of Moses. This wasn't just a clever literary device; ancient rabbis asserted "that the latter redeemer would mirror the first." Matthew was arguing within a recognized Jewish framework that Jesus was the expected ultimate redeemer.
The parallels are direct and dramatic. A tyrannical ruler, King Herod, echoes Pharaoh in his paranoia about a newborn king who threatens his power. Josephus records Herod’s brutal and suspicious nature, which led Caesar Augustus to quip that it was "safer to be Herod’s pig than his son." This fear drives Herod to order the mass slaughter of male infants in Bethlehem, mirroring Pharaoh's decree in Egypt. The hero's family must then flee into exile, with Jesus’s flight to Egypt serving as a direct inversion of the Exodus story.
The most striking parallel, however, comes when the danger has passed. Matthew’s use of language powerfully mirrors the Exodus account.
"Matthew recounts the angel’s command: ‘Get up, take the child and his mother and go to the land of Israel, for those who were trying to take the child’s life are dead’ (Mt 2:20). This statement subtly echoes the Exodus narrative: ‘Go back to Egypt, for all those who wanted to kill you are dead’ (Ex 4:19)."
By patterning Jesus's birth on Moses's, Matthew makes a profound claim. He argues that Jesus is the new Moses, the one who will lead God's people in a new and greater Exodus—a spiritual deliverance from the bondage of sin and death.
3. Jesus's Family Tree Is Full of Scandalous and Surprising Women.
Ancient Jewish genealogies were almost exclusively patrilineal, tracing lineage from father to son. The mention of women was highly unusual, which makes Matthew's decision to include five of them a deliberate and impactful choice. Beyond Mary, he names four women from the Old Testament, each with a story marked by irregularity or scandal. In one flowing paragraph, he lists Tamar, who secured her legal rights and the continuation of Judah's line by posing as a prostitute after being wronged by her family; Rahab, a Canaanite prostitute from Jericho who aided the Israelite spies; Ruth, a foreigner from Moab, an enemy nation of Israel; and "the wife of Uriah" (Bathsheba), whose union with King David began in adultery and led to the murder of her husband, a scandal that haunted David's reign.
Matthew's inclusion of these women serves a brilliant dual purpose in his narrative. First, many were Gentiles, foreshadowing from the very first chapter that Jesus's mission would extend beyond Israel to bless all nations. Second, their irregular stories—involving deception, foreign status, and sexual scandal—demonstrate God's power to work through messy human history and flawed individuals. This theme powerfully prepares the reader for the scandal of Mary's own pre-marital, Spirit-wrought pregnancy, showing that God's plan has always moved forward in unexpected and even shocking ways.
4. The "Three Kings" Were Not Kings, and There Weren't Necessarily Three.
The image of "We Three Kings of Orient Are" is cemented in Christmas tradition, but it's a significant departure from what Matthew's Gospel actually describes.
The text is the only biblical source for their visit, and it refers to them not as kings, but as "Magi from the east" (Greek: magoi). The Magi were likely Persian or Babylonian astrologers, possibly from the learned Zoroastrian priestly caste, known for their skill in interpreting celestial events. The idea that they were kings developed around the 3rd century, as Christians sought to connect their visit with Old Testament prophecies about kings coming to worship the Messiah.
Furthermore, the number three is only a tradition based on the three gifts mentioned: gold, frankincense, and myrrh. Matthew never specifies how many Magi there were. In fact, other traditions, particularly in Syriac Christianity, suggest there were twelve. Even their famous names—Caspar, Melchior, and Balthazar—are a much later addition, first appearing in a Greek manuscript from the 8th century.
5. Joseph, the Obedient Dreamer, Is the Narrative's Unsung Hero.
While Mary is the central figure in Luke’s Christmas story, Matthew’s narrative is told almost entirely from Joseph’s perspective. He is the central human protagonist whose actions drive the plot and ensure the fulfillment of God’s plan.
The story hinges on four crucial moments when an angel appears to Joseph in a dream (Greek: kat' onar). These dreams were not symbolic visions needing interpretation like those of the Old Testament Joseph; they were direct, oral messages delivering divine commands:
1. To take Mary as his wife, despite her seemingly scandalous pregnancy.
2. To flee with Mary and Jesus to Egypt to escape Herod's wrath.
3. To return from Egypt after Herod's death.
4. To settle in Galilee to avoid Herod's equally ruthless son.
Matthew describes Joseph as "righteous" (dikaios), meaning he was a devout Jew committed to obeying God's Law. His initial plan to "divorce her quietly" was his attempt to be righteous—balancing the law's demands against his personal mercy. This makes his subsequent obedience to the dream, which required him to defy both social convention and a surface-level reading of the law, even more heroic. Joseph's quiet, unwavering obedience is the human hinge on which the entire narrative turns, making him a powerful model of faith.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conclusion: A Story for the Head and the Heart
Matthew's Christmas story, therefore, is not a simple chronicle but a masterclass in theological argument. Through the literary DNA of Moses, the ghosts of Israel's prophets, the whispers of scandalous ancestors, and the quiet obedience of a righteous dreamer, Matthew presents a Christ who is not just born into history, but who is the climax of all history. He crafts a story designed to challenge assumptions and reveal the intricate ways God works in the world.
Knowing these hidden layers, how might the familiar story of Christmas challenge or deepen our understanding of this season?